It is becoming quite common at some of the local clubs for whoever is under the gun to check in the dark no matter what. Almost 50% of the time they raise blind and then decline their option to re-raise and then check in the dark. Are these guys hidden poker geniuses? Is there some advantage that I do not understand about the move? Or are these guys just watching to much poker on TV and trying to hard be one of the cool kids.
After having spent some time thinking about all the situations in which it might be useful and I am not coming up with a lot. But lets go through the factors that is your goal, what would make a difference on it.
Goal:
- Get a free card?
- Get a check raise?
- Throw off a excellent hand reader?
- Pure bluffs.
Factors:
- Blind Checking to different players types LAGS vs TAGS.
- Blind Checking with certain hand types, small pocket pair, big pocket pairs, small connectors, big aces.
- Blind Checking to different #’s of players.
- Blind Checking to very good hand readers or not.
- Blind Checking after raising pre-flop or not
Goal of getting a free card. There might be something to this but I would say a lot of conditions have to line up for this to work. Say you have a very drawing hand that rarely flops and often needs to get to the turn before it becomes a good drawing hand. ie small suited connectors that often flop 2 or more runner runner draws . In this case against a mostly tight passive table I could see this sometimes working. If you have an aggressive image some people might not bet their middle or bottom pair because they might fear a re-raise from you since you did not get to act yet. They might check it one time and see what you do on the turn. In the end I am not sure this is worth it as the amount of times you get a free card is not going to make up for the # of times you hit something that you would want to attack a tight passive table with. And if you do hit something with a tight passive table, you will be giving them a free card to outdraw you as they almost always check.
Goal of getting a check raise. Not likely to work with a tight table, might work with a very LAG table but then again just checking to a LAG table normally and someone will bet. Plus you have to hit the flop or already have something big and hope it is not dangerous so that if someone does not bet that they do not get a free card. Seems like for a check raise it is better to wait and see how dangerous the flop is before committing.
Throw off a expert hand reader. Maybe, the only lines I can think of were it would help is with the small pairs, you blind check and if you hit a set and there is a big card out there then if someone bets and you re-raise they may put you on the big card rather than the set and give you more action if they have top pair top kicker or two pair. This is pretty rare case and not worth worrying about. Most readers will pick up on what your showing down pretty quickly so the confusion part will be short lived. Other cases might be flopping a str8 flush draw, two pair or other hands that you would go to war with and there is an Ace or King out there that they can put you on. But what your giving up for it is too much, I would wait for a safe flop before trying to play it tricky just for the good hand readers.
Make it easier to throw down a pure check raise bluff. Yes this almost make sense, you called / raises under the gun you could have any pairs, big face cards, maybe even some suited connectors. If anyone bets the flop and you can go ahead and re-raise and they will think for a min that you might have it. Now you can not do it to often before they realize you just picking of pots, but once in awhile it can work. But to do that it means you have to do a lot of checking dark which means giving up control in other pots that you do not want to and calling under the gun with junk some times. Plus if your bluff does not work that now means you play the rest of the hand out of position. Does all this extra set up that you have to do to make them work outweigh the benefit you get from the successful bluff. In my experience it does, the only time this bluff is any more effective than a normal check raise bluff is when the board has draws on it and you bet really big so they can believe you would have bet it if you had the chance to protect your hand.
Conclusion, I can see a little tiny bit of benefit to doing it with the small pocket pairs for deception value if they hit and there are big cards out there. If you do give off a free card though be ready to not go broke with it and it is not the end of the world as you have a re-draw. If you have a tight image you can try it and maybe pull off some re-steal bluffs against your weaker players, believe me your good players will catch onto what your doing really quickly and start coming back over the top.
Anyone got any other reasons to check dark, I would like to hear them, leave me comments.